I've made up my mind to buy, but wich one?
- 21st September 2005 | permanent link
- comments (23)
First of all why a laptop?
Trendy? Geeky? Fashionable? No. I just think I'm not as productive behind the desk as I could be if I'm mobile. I can bring my laptop to client meetings and show them the current project phase on the laptop instead of looking for a computer with internet connection and uploading everything to a server from home (OK, I guess it works, but I'm getting a bit tired of it all). Another reason is WiFi with quite a few access point in my city. The list goes on and on as you can imagine.
Desired specs
Recently I helped a friend pick out a laptop. It wasn't hard because she didn't need much, but as a programer and designer wannabe I'm looking for more. Much more. This is what I'm looking for:
- At least 1.8 GHz Centrino (or an AMD equivalent) with 2MB L2 cache
- 512 or 1024 MB of RAM. I usualy have quite a few programs open at the same time so I guess this is a must
- 15.4 inch screen with a resolution close to or above 1280 x 1024. Mostly because I get really clastrofobic (I don't really know if this is the right fobia to use, I just hate small screen resolutions, and no I don't want to get cured)
- 128 MB Graphic card. Don't really care wich one as long it's optimized for laptops
- 60 (or above) GB hard drive with 5400rpm
- DVD +/- RW, don't really need dual layer
- 4-5 hours of battery life
- WiFi, LAN and all the stuff you get weather you need it or not
Yeah, I know. Quite a spec list, and all of this adds up to a nice 'little' stack of money, so I'm already pondering a few plans for bank robbery.
So far so, well, not so good
Currently I'm looking at this Compaq HP (sorry only in Slovene, I couldn't find an english page, wich seems strange, the price is 2190 Euro), and I've been thinking, am I only paying for the brand or are those things really so expensive?
But then again, buying a never-before-heard-of brand is not my coup of tea either. I like all of the components to work (lets say) five years from now. That's also the main reason I'm mostly looking at Compaq HP 'cause everybody I know that have them are very satisfied.
Also I'm concidering this Prestigio. Looks nice, but don't know anybody that has it. Even an Apple PowerBook has found it's place amongst my choices, but I have never worked on a Mac, so I'm not so thrilled about them as the rest of the world. Don't get me wrong, I would love to have one, but it happens to be quite a sum of money for me, so I'm trying to be as careful as possible.
I'm open to suggestions
What do you have? How much did you pay and how satisfied are you with your laptop.


I have some good experiences with HP Compaq notebooks, so I can recommend it to you.
The price is aprox 1482 Euro. Looks real promising :)
but if you want the PC one...I'd say HP.
Although Chili green are nice too :)
I've seen a lot of people with HPs and worked a lot on them also, and they are really powerfull and it's really great to work on them (David would certanly agree ;))
But the thing with HPs is that they are really expensive (if you decide to buy one that has everything you want)...
On the other hand, Chili green (http://www.chiligreen.com), has really powerfull computers also, but they are a lot cheaper than HPs (given the same specifications). I have a 15,2" Chili at home with a AMD Athlon 3000 proc. and 512MB ram...with a built in DVD+RW and all that other crap...and I must say I love working on it...even though it's a PC :D It's also small, light and nicely designed... plus it costed just about 1.000€ which is cheap for a computer like that.
But as far as powerbooks are concerned (and other Apple laptops)... If you intend to use it for serious work, I would have to advise you to wait for the next generation of them (even though I am a total Apple fan, but these G4 notebooks are really outdated (although the G4 is still a quite powerfull proc.)...They'll release the intel based notebooks soon and then, it'll be poetry :D
btw, chili and mac, no go doen :P
I recommend Prestigio (Unless you have a really really big pocket :))
It's a bad thing that the market here is too small for Apple to put it's own Apple Store™ here :(
Besides the obvious reason (unbeatable O.S. and software), Apple laptops are *not* more expensive than equivalent-quality MS-Windows-laptops, if you\'re comparing models with similar specs.
My current machine is still a (quite abused) 2002 PBG4 Tibook, it even fell on the floor upside-down while turned on and open (!!!) and nothing happened to it. Luck? Maybe yes, but also excellent manufacturing. Try that with a VAIO or a Dell...
If you are a student, you can\'t go wrong with the once-in-a-lifetime student developer discount. Check:
http://developer.apple.com/students/sthardware.html
Get a Powerbook, you won\'t regret it!
Also, touchpad, mouse dongle (whateverit'scalled), Combo drive (6 months old), vents in the back, keyboard... everything is dying on me. I can't install anything unless it's on the harddrive because my rom won't work. I have 2 weeks fresh OS and it sucks donkey balls (haha, I love that one). Get an Apple computer. That's my opinion. Price!? Seems way more expensive, but when you really really compare the prices, you realise that you are on the same level or even better off with an Apple computer. It just brings so much more value into your results when working with the computer. But in the end it's still your choice, of course. For me, I just hope my portable will not die completely on me before the new intel based Powerbooks come out.
What are your experiences when switching to a Mac? How fast did you catch on and how different is the OS acctualy. OK I know the core is FreeBSD, so it isn't so different. And what about comunication between a PC and Mac? Any comments on that?
And you've seen what the lowest end eMac 1GHz with 640MB SDRAM can do, how many apps at once and no issues with performance, remember? If I were you I would wait for the intel powerbook. It will be worth the wait and in the mean time put more $$$ on the side for some extra muscle!
My friend has a 400MHz, 256MB RAM, 10GB hdd 15" powerbook (the old one) and it's still performing the same as my Dell 1.6GHz P4 mobile with 640MB RAM running Winblows (and it's a clean install). Go figure.
Also I did check up on the Intel PowerBooks, but the only info I could gather is that they will come out in late 2006...
Are here some people that have an prestigio 1590W at home? It is good?
Guess not. I haven't gotten around to buying one, but from what I hear they aren't so bad. But for the time beeing I'm sticking with HP :)